bertgwen wrote:As an aside, anyone have any info on the new place at the old Gotham location (beyond what's been in the paper)?
You may have the location of the original Gotham confused with something else; Gotham on Mifflin -- the original location -- remains open and unchanged.
Or by "old" do you mean "former"?
On-topic: If you're losing Gotham on Park and considering 4 & 20, then clearly you aren't framing your hunt on a commuter route. The entire city is at your disposal. In that case, consider the classic breakfast sandwich at Mermaid, or the sandwich at Heritage Bakery and Cafe on Cottage Grove Rd. Crema Cafe has a very fine breakfast sandwich, but with all the construction on Monona, "easy in/out" is easier said than done.